Are Steven Pinker's Numbers Cooked?

Steven Pinker is a favourite for bougie lefties looking for reassurance that everything's ok

Steven Pinker makes a pretty strong argument using statistics to demonstrate that mankind has been making steady progress on social ills like violence over time.

David Graeber questions the validity of these statistics and asked if there were any available statistics that "prove" a different narrative. Pinker accused David of simply ignoring the empirical data based on ideology (something David accuses Pinker of doing, or at least selecting statistics that fit his narrative).

I thought about this for awhile, and in the shower just now it hit me...there ARE statistics that paint a very different picture, they come from the emerging field of economic inequality. We are getting more data every year thanks to an explosion in research on the topic. So what does the research show so far? In Wilkinson and Pickett's 'The Inner Level' they track a range of social ills from violent crime to overall health and teenage delinquency, and on every single one, when comparing the available statistics from different countries, things are worse in more unequal countries. So things like violent crime track with the level of inequality, not overall wealth. It's not how rich or poor your country is that produces bad results, it's how unequal it is.

So if social ills track with inequality and inequality gets more severe over time, it follows that social ills get more severe over time, not less. Or to put it another way, if we are experiencing the highest levels of inequality in human history and inequality is linked to domestic violence, sexual assault, poor educational outcomes, increased status competition, poorer mental health, etc, then Pinker's figures must be wrong.

I thought all this then Googled "Wilkinson Pickett Pinker" and found out that I'm not the first person to think this.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/feb/18/letters-inequality-poverty-steven-pinker

I still need some time to think this through.

Comments

Blog Name Change

My blog will be shifting focus... I'm saying goodbye to the old citizen zero, because I don't feel like much of a citizen. So the title now reads 'Denizen One: Voice of The Precariat', rather than 'Citizen Zero: Your Voice Counts'. A small change, but an important one. I am currently reading Guy Standing's The Precariat, and I quite like some of the ideas. Stay tuned.

Kandiaronk on Law and Punishment

Excerpt from 'The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity' by David Graeber and David Wengrow Lahontan: This is why the wicked need to be punished, and the good need to be rewarded. Otherwise, murder, robbery and defamation would spread everywhere, and, in a word, we would become the most miserable people upon the face of the earth. Kandiaronk: For my own part, I find it hard to see how you could be much more miserable than you already are. What kind of human, what species of creature, must Europeans be, that they have to be forced to do good, and only refrain from evil because of fear of punishment?... You have observed that we lack judges. What is the reason for that? Well, we never bring lawsuits against one another. And why do we never bring lawsuits? Well, because we made a decision neither to accept or make use of money. And why do we refuse to allow money into our communities? The reason is this: we are determined not to have laws – because, since the world was a w...

Heroic Employers Vs Lazy Jobseekers - Cafe Rant

The state treats the precariat as necessary but as a group to be criticized, pitied, demonized, sanctioned or penalized in turn, not as a focus of social protection or betterment of well-being. -Guy Standing, 'A Precariat Charter' Before I get into this, just a quick reminder that I am actually going through a very hard time, experiencing violence and bullying at home (I live in a public housing block). I deal with it by getting out of the house as soon as I wake and not returning until I am exhausted enough to pass out. I do these posts on the fly, on the move and under extreme duress, so you'll have to excuse the rushed nature of both the text and audio. I truly appreciate anyone who is prepared to hear what I have to say, especially considering the clunky format. One thing I did forget to mention in my little rave here is that the job seekers we are speaking about have for the most part lost all their bargaining power and are coerced into accepting whatever wages ...

Search This Blog